Robyn & Nance try the same recipe – Honey Sauced Chicken

Every Monday, we’ll post a recipe that we both made. This week’s recipe was from   Chelsea at Mmm…Cafe.

Nance’s take:

This week it was Robyn’s turn to pick the recipe.  I was kind of nervous because I’m well aware that Robyn is a huge lover of vegetables.  Now my favorite vegetable is corn (with lots of butter) with my second being potatoes (also with lots of butter).  Robyn eats stuff like squash and okra on a regular basis (and she doesn’t even have the sense to deep fry it).  I think you get where I’m coming from here.  One of us is way more healthier than the other.  Ahem.  I was also in a tizzy because the only rule (for lack of a better word) that I dictated about this venture is no seafood (I hate seafood more than I hate my ex-husband and that’s saying some shit).  Now before you all get yourselves into a snit please note that the rule is only for the tandem recipes.  Miz Robyn may post as many seafood recipes as she would want on here.  She just can’t make me cook them.  Heh.

So the first recipe that Robyn threw at me:  Some kind of garlic shrimp mess and OHHELLNO!  I suppose I should add that I didn’t tell Robyn of the no seafood rule because I figured she would already know that…because we’re friends and friends don’t let friends eat stuff that lives in its own toilet!  Some friend she is.  Hmph.

After a flurry of emails denouncing seafood, etc., she sent me her second choice recipe.  Honey Sauced Chicken.  I was all happy because I like honey and I like chicken!  And then I saw the soy sauce and I was all, “Oh, barf!”   But I decided to suck it up because nobody likes a big baby (or a picky eater).  Wah, wah, wah.

I’m one of those knuckleheads that only reads the ingredient list when looking at a recipe.  The other stuff is what happens when you actually go to make it.  So I never realized that it was supposed to be made in a crock-pot until about 5:30.  Oops!  Fortunately, she includes instructions on how to make it a 30 minute meal.  So that’s what I did.

There are days when things that I do in the kitchen are effortless.  And then there are days when it has to be a todo.  Can you guess what day this was?  I’ll give you a hint.  Iced tea AND coffee cup sitting in my area.  I was obviously having a time of it.  And things didn’t get any better once I realized that I sprayed my dish with Pam…for baking!  I wiped it out and started over.  Sigh.  The recipe doesn’t even call for doing that, but I wasn’t about to have a sticky (hello, honey!) mess all burned up in my dish (I tend to ignore things once I put them in the oven, including the oven timer at times, heh) so I took the extra precaution.

I also doubled the recipe (there are four of us eating).  We (and by we I mean Rick because he’s the resident math dork over here) figured out that 3/4 of a pound of chicken doubled would be about two of those giant chicken breasts you get at Sam’s club.

I was an adult before I liked honey. Isn’t it weird how your taste changes over the years?

This is what it looked like before I put it in the oven. I have to admit I was a little nervous because I had visions of serving up a hearty bowl of soy soup.

I spooned it over rice and was pretty dubious about the whole mess because the sauce had not thickened like I expected it to. I had it in my head that it was going to be like Chinese take-out Sweet and Sour chicken. I then remembered once eating General Tso’s chicken over shredded lettuce so I decided to try it that way.

It was FABULOUS. And the rice eaters loved it too! Everyone agreed that it should go into our family meal rotation and that right there is a freaking miracle!



Robyn’s Side

Okay, look. To be fair, when I suggested the garlic shrimp recipe to Nance, I DID say “I know you hate seafood, so probably not this one?”

I’m pretty sure that “lover of vegetables” is going to need to go on my tombstone because that cracked me up. I have a friend (this is not Nance I’m talking about, for the record) who eats vegetables so rarely that when she does, it’s a noteworthy event and a couple of weeks ago she posted on Facebook that she’d eaten a salad for dinner and we were all “!!!!!!!!!!!!!” Also, she loathes peas and considers their existence to be a personal affront.


I have a habit of seeing a recipe that looks interesting to me, and printing it out. I have a stack of recipes at least six inches high, dating back three or four years (every so often I go through them and admit that there are several that I’m never going to make), and so when it was my turn to choose a recipe, I grabbed my stack and picked one I thought Nance might be okay with.

(Fred is not super crazy about soy sauce, and since Nance and Fred think alike about MANY things – I’m pretty sure they were separated at birth – I wasn’t sure Nance would go for it. But she decided to be adventurous!)

Your ingredients:


I’d already chopped up the chicken (and salt and peppered it) earlier in the day because I like to get the annoying prep stuff done beforehand. 3/4 pounds of chicken breasts equaled three chicken breasts from our (free-range) chickens. You’ve also got honey (the big-ass bottle from Sam’s. How often do I use honey? How many years do you think I’ll be using honey from that bottle, for god’s sake? It’s already at least a year old! I love Sam’s, but there are some things a two-person household doesn’t really need to buy in bulk). There’s soy sauce, 1/8 cup chopped onion, ketchup, minced garlic, red pepper flakes, and the big-ass bottle of olive oil from Sam’s. The recipe calls for vegetable oil, but the generic “vegetable oil” we have on hand smells funny so I opted for the olive oil.

This recipe really could not be easier – put the chicken in the baking dish, mix up the sauce and pour it over, stick the whole thing in the oven.

(The recipe I printed out has crock pot instructions, but I’m trying to convince y’all that I can make dinner without using the crock pot, so I opted for the oven instructions.)


I hate handling raw chicken, by the way. It ooks me out.

Bake for 10 minutes, stir it, bake another 10, and voila it is ready. We had ours over angel hair.


Fred’s not a huge fan of rice, he’ll always prefer pasta if given the choice. I really like Nance’s idea of eating it over chopped lettuce and will probably give that a try next time around.

I really liked this a lot – Fred, on the other hand, was more lukewarm about it. I think he might like it more if the sauce was thicker, so next time I make it I’m going to add some cornstarch to the sauce and see if I can’t get it to thicken up a bit. If I can’t get him to like it as much as I do, I’ll likely add it to my own personal rotation and eat it for lunches during the week. Two thumbs up from me, and a “Meh” from Fred, that picky motherfucker.


Robyn & Nance try the same recipe - Honey Sauced Chicken
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Original Source/Author:
: Entree, Main, Chicken
Serves: 2
  • ¾ lb chicken (we used boneless skinless chicken breasts)
  • ½ tsp salt
  • ¼ tsp black pepper
  • ½ c. honey
  • ¼ c. soy sauce
  • ⅛ c. chopped onion (or 1/16 c. onion flakes)
  • ⅛ c. ketchup
  • 1 T vegetable oil
  • 1 clove minced garlic
  • ¼ t red pepper flakes
  1. Season both sides of chicken with salt and pepper. Put into crock pot.
  2. Mix remaining ingredients and pour over the chicken.
  3. Cook on low for 3 hours or high 1½ hours.
  4. Remove chicken from the crock pot, cut into bite sized pieces, then return to pot and toss with sauce.
  5. Serve over rice or noodles or shredded lettuce.
  6. Baking instructions:
  7. Season chicken with salt and pepper; dice into bite-sized pieces.
  8. Place chicken in 8x8 pan.
  9. Mix remaining ingredients in small bowl; pour over chicken.
  10. Bake at 350 for 20 minutes, stirring halfway through.



Robyn & Nance try the same recipe – Honey Sauced Chicken — 32 Comments

  1. This looks tasty.I think I will nestle it on a bed of chopped romaine. Don’t ask me where that goofy ass way of stating it came from.

  2. I think the next time I make it I’m going to try and use that “fake” honey that Walmart sales (can’t remember the name right now!). And I didn’t even bother with the oil because I sprayed my casserole dish.

  3. Mmmm…I love Nance’s idea of turning it into a salad!

    I’m putting in a request for you guys to try PW’s Nantucket cranberry pie (although I suspect it really isn’t her recipe). I thought about fixing it this past Christmas but I was scared that it might be a flop and I think it’s hard for her commenters to say anything that might offend her.

    • Why you gotta punish me with one of Pioneer Woman’s recipes? Gah! It’s not hard for her commenters to say anything that might offend her because rumor has it that there are never any offensive comments since they are always deleted. Now mind you, that’s idle gossip, but one has to wonder why one has never seen a “bad” comment ever, huh?

      But, because I love you (more than my luggage* – bwahaha) I’m gonna go check out the recipe to see if it’s something Robyn and I might want to make. But I’m telling you right now that there will be a poll put up the week before for everyone to guess whether the recipe turns out or not!

      *it has always disturbed me that she uses that phrase on the regular without giving proper credit to Steel Magnolias.

      • Did you just call me a blogger? And whatever gave you the idea that we care? LOL

        I think you (and everyone else) will find that there are some bloggers “made” to think that they are “better than” when they hit what they think is the big time and then there are normal people who were raised right and try there best. 🙂

      • I can confirm that PW rumor. I posted a not-even-really-negative comment about the Dr Pepper pork not being a winner and it was gone within 24 hours. Some of her recipes ARE good – there’s a pumpkin carmael cheesecake that was really really good – but it pisses me off to no end that 99% of her commenters wax on and on about how good a recipe is BEFORE they make it. It’s not a crime to instead say “Hmmm, this didn’t really taste like I was expecting it to taste. Won’t be making it again” and someone who’s insecure enough to remove honest comments is 500 kinds of shady.

      • She’s the only woman I know who has bullshitted her way to fame while talking about keeping it real at the same time. I feel bad for her kids.

        And also…

        Y’all think Robyn is building a gym in that garage, but I’m secretly wondering if she’s working on a television studio like “The Lodge”. Hee!

  4. Would you be willing to post the crock pot version? I’d be curious to know if the sauce would thicken up if cooked that way.

    • You have to shred the lettuce into long, thin strips. One day I tried some of Rick’s take-out General Tso’s over regular ol’ salad lettuce and it sucked. I have no idea why, but it has to be in long, thin strips to work. Of course, it could just be that I’m a weirdo. 🙂

  5. This looks totally up my alley, and my happy ass WILL be making it for dinner tomorrow night! I especially love that the sauce ingredients are all basic pantry items.

    • OK, I made it last night and it was FABULOUS just as written, but I think next time I’ll increase the soy sauce a bit, to make it just a bit less sweet. I think it was Robyn that said she would thicken the sauce with some cornstarch next time, and I think I’ll do the same. Overall, two big thumbs up. Thanks, y’all!

  6. HUGE hit at my house! We all loved it. I was worried about over sweetness ( I doubled the batch and used a cup of honey) but it was perfect! Thanks I got something new to add to the rotation around here!

  7. So I made this in the crockpot, and it was delicious. I made another change in that I added some asian style vegetables to the dish in the last 30 minutes of cooking. That helped thicken the sauce too, but I guess it only works if you like vegetables (which I do).

  8. Yummy. Had this on Friday night. Over rice. I liked the flavor but I would add a little corn starch as Robyn mentioned just to thicken the sause a little. It reminds me of a teriyaki sauch be not as bitey. I like the sweeter flavor. I will definitely put this in the rotation. The house smelled really good while this was cooking.

  9. This sounds good. If I had chicken breasts, I’d make this tonight. I have nothing planned. Maybe even good with some shredded cabbage. I bought bagged cole slaw yesterday. I made the mistake of buying soy sauce at Costco once. Had that bottle forever. Now I just steal packets from the Chinese restaurant.

    • I made this and we really liked it. I added part of a bag of frozen broccoli cuts and some cut up red bell pepper. Sorry Nance. I really liked the veggies in it. It added to the cooking time. Don’t know if it was because the broccoli was frozen or it made the pan too full. Broccoli tasted really good and was soft. Maybe next time I’ll cook the broccoli a little and add it halfway thru.

      • Ooh, I like the idea of adding broccoli – that makes it a meal all by itself, with no side dishes needed! 🙂

Comments (%)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *